Henry Gordon BENNETT CB, CMG, DSO, MID

BENNETT, Henry Gordon

Service Numbers: Commissioned Officer, N76069, NX70343
Enlisted: 19 August 1914, Second in Command
Last Rank: Lieutenant General
Last Unit: 8th Division Headquarters
Born: Balwyn, Victoria, Australia, 16 April 1887
Home Town: Elizabeth Bay, City of Sydney, New South Wales
Schooling: Balwyn State School and Hawthorn College, Victoria, Australia
Occupation: Accountant
Died: Natural causes, Dural, New South Wales, Australia, 1 August 1962, aged 75 years
Cemetery: Rookwood Cemetery & Crematorium
Cremated
Memorials:
Show Relationships

World War 1 Service

19 Aug 1914: Enlisted AIF WW1, Major, Commissioned Officer, 6th Infantry Battalion, Second in Command
19 Oct 1914: Embarked AIF WW1, Major, Commissioned Officer, 6th Infantry Battalion, --- :embarkation_roll: roll_number: '8' embarkation_place: Melbourne embarkation_ship: HMAT Hororata embarkation_ship_number: A20 public_note: ''
25 Apr 1915: Wounded AIF WW1, Major, Commissioned Officer, 6th Infantry Battalion, ANZAC / Gallipoli, Wounded at Pine Ridge
25 Apr 1915: Involvement AIF WW1, Major, Commissioned Officer, 6th Infantry Battalion, ANZAC / Gallipoli
9 May 1915: Involvement AIF WW1, Major, Commissioned Officer, 6th Infantry Battalion, ANZAC / Gallipoli, Appointed as Commanding Officer of the 6th Battalion after the wounding of LTCOL McNicol at Krithia
20 May 1915: Promoted AIF WW1, Lieutenant Colonel, 6th Infantry Battalion, Appointment as CO confirmed
23 Jul 1916: Involvement AIF WW1, Lieutenant Colonel, Commissioned Officer, 6th Infantry Battalion, Battle for Pozières
3 Dec 1916: Promoted AIF WW1, Brigadier General, 3rd Infantry Brigade Headquarters, Aged 29 youngest Brigadier in the Army

World War 2 Service

30 Sep 1940: Enlisted Lieutenant Colonel, N76069, 8th Division Headquarters
7 Dec 1941: Involvement Major General, Commissioned Officer, 8th Division Headquarters, Malaya/Singapore, Bennett escaped from Singapore and returned to Australia. He was vilified, yet US General MacArthur who did exactly the same thing, was lauded a hero.
9 May 1944: Discharged Lieutenant General, NX70343, 8th Division Headquarters
Date unknown: Involvement AIF WW1, Major General

WW1

The details provided are taken from the book "Stealth Raiders - a few daring men in 1918" written by Lucas Jordan, published 2017 - refer to pages 114 + 168 + 262. Prior to the war he was a soldier of Canterbury Vic. He enlisted in the AIF 19 Aug 1914 aged 27 years. During the war he advanced in promotion eventually achieving the rank of Brigadier and during the war he was awarded the CB, CMG, DSO, MID + MD 3rd class. He left the UK for Australia 15 May 1919.

Showing 1 of 1 story

Biography contributed by Faithe Jones

Amidst the myriad of controversial senior officers in the Australian military during the Second World War, Gordon Bennett is by far the most controversial. It must be acknowledged that there a different reasons for controversy, four being evident to the casual observer of human nature: some may be associated with ill-fated ventures, have performed ignoble deeds, be in possession of ignoble character, or be in conflict with controversial superiors. Bennett was in possession of all four, all of which will become evident upon a glance at a summary of his life.

Henry Gordon Bennett was born in Balwyn, a suburb of Melbourne, near the close of the nineteenth century. He tried a career as an actuarial clerk, attending Hawthorn College after Balwyn State School. He might not have achieved such infamy had he remained an actuarial clerk, but in 1908 he was commissioned into the militia, and posted to the 5th Infantry Regiment, promoted to major in 1912. When a bullet fired from Gavrilo Princip's gun barrel tore into Archduke Franz Ferdinand's flesh in Sarajevo, sparking the First World War, Bennett was transferred to the 1st AIF. He was dispatched from Australia in 1914 as second in command of the 6th Battalion. Landing at Gallipoli early on the morning of 25 April 1915, Bennett was wounded that afternoon. He was evacuated on a hospital ship, but decided those circumstances were not in keeping with a reputation of courage and leadership that he had developed. He returned to the front line as commander of the 2nd Brigade, which he led in the assault on Turkish positions at Krithia on 8 May. The next day he was promoted to temporary lieutenant colonel and given command of the 6th Battalion, which he led in fighting on the Western Front. There he continued his reputation for bravery and leadership, but got a reputation of a different kind: he was known by fellow officers as a prickly, jealous, and querulous man, traits that would become evident during later years. At war's end, Bennett switched from military to civilian pursuits: in 1916 he married Bessie Buchanan. During the interwar years Bennett found employment in Sydney as an accountant and clothing manufacturer. He sat on the NSW State Repatriation Board, becoming one of the three commissioners for the city of Sydney. In 1931-33 he presided over the NSW Chamber of Manufacturers. All this time he remained in the military, in 1926 he took command of the 2nd Division.

Despite an unblemished record of courage and strong leadership in the First World War, Bennett was an old-fashioned soldier, and a new war was on the horizon. When Blamey was appointed commander of the 6th Division, Bennett nursed a grudge against him that lasted the entire length of the war. Anger at someone else getting this appointment rather than him may sound like a small matter for which anger is unjustifiable, but Blamey's appointment to the 6th Division is more significant than it sounds: at the time the 2nd AIF was expected to grow to five divisions like it had in the First World War, and Blamey had been third in line for the position with Bennett and Lavarack higher in rank than Blamey at the time, yet both were passed over in favour of Blamey for reasons of war cabinet politics and preferences. Still, it was Bennett's jealous character that turned the misguided rage towards Blamey, he was just the war cabinet's choice for the position, and John Lavarack did not harbour similar ill feeling towards Blamey. Bennett's pettiness and anger would have made him a poor choice anyway, he could have reserved his energy, even though he did not initially get appointed to the command of the 7th, 8th or 9th Divisions, strange things happen in wartime. The Chief of the General Staff, Brudenell White died in a plane crash in Canberra on 13 August 1940, and the commander of the 8th Division, Vernon Sturdee, was promoted into White's position. Sturdee nominated Bennett as the new commander of the 8th Division. In 1941 the 8th Division was assigned with aiding the defence of Malaya and Singapore. This was a difficult task, the British had not made adequate preparations for the defence of the centerpiece of imperial defence strategy. Bennett, at 54 years of age, was not up to this task physically, after an extensive medical examination Alf Derham, the 8th Division's senior medical officer observed:

"he is not robust even for his age, gets overtired easily, and seems to feel the effects of the strain unduly. It is my opinion as a medical officer that he is too old for active service in the field and that he would not stand the strain of operations for more than a few weeks at most."
It was not merely Bennett's physical condition that was too fragile for active command in the field, according to his chief of staff, Colonel Jim Thyer:

"Between the wars he was a civilian and did not study military tactics, but rested on his World War I laurels. He was moved by hunches and believed in the stars. He was tremendously ambitious and had his head in the clouds, which is the last place a good battle commander's head should be."
This was the commander assigned with halting Yamashita's advance down the Malay Peninsula at Johore. An ambush, executed with devastating effect, at Gemas was a welcome success in Allied operations on the Malay Peninsula. The Australian 2/30th Battalion set up observation posts overlooking the bridge over the Gemencheh River, once a thousand Japanese cyclists had crossed the bridge, it was blown up. The cornered Japanese soldiers, separated from the bulk of their army, were then the target of grenades and concentrated machine gun fire. Once Singapore Island fell, Bennett was at the centre of the plethora of excuses for the controversial fall, he accused the British commanders of a "retreat complex" and the 8th Division and its physically and mentally unfit commander were accused in turn by the British commanders of looting, rape, fighting their way onto evacuation ships, and other breaches of discipline. The Australians were not the only ones to crack under the pressure of the victorious Japanese advance. Bennett escaped on a civilian evacuation ship, claiming that Australia needed his expertise in fighting the Japanese. In June 1942 the British took the final step in the search for scapegoats for the fall of Singapore, Wavell publicly held Bennett responsible for the debacle.

https://ww2db.com/person_bio.php?person_id=c470

Read more...

Biography contributed by Steve Larkins

Major General Henry Gordon BENNETT CB, CMG, DSO, MiD*** (1887-1962)

Australian Dictionary of Biography

Henry Gordon Bennett (1887-1962), army officer and businessman, was born on 16 April 1887 at Balwyn, Melbourne, second child of George Jesse Bennett, a schoolmaster from Cape Town, and his native-born wife Harriet, née Bentley. Alfred Edward Bennett was Gordon's younger brother. Educated at Balwyn State School and Hawthorn College, Gordon was employed by the Australian Mutual Provident Society as an actuarial clerk. On 14 August 1908 he was commissioned in the Citizen Military Forces and posted to the 5th Infantry Regiment. He was promoted major in 1912.

Transferring to the Australian Imperial Force on 19 August 1914, Bennett embarked for Egypt in October as second-in-command of the 6th Battalion. In the Gallipoli landings of 25 April 1915 he was one of the leaders of the advance to Pine Ridge. Wounded that afternoon while directing fire at Turkish positions, he was evacuated to a hospital ship, but absented himself to return to the front. He gained a reputation for leadership and courage under fire—and for his seeming immunity to serious injury—particularly in the 2nd Brigade's assault against Krithia on 8 May. Next day he was promoted temporary lieutenant colonel and assumed command of the 6th Battalion. Overlooked for this advancement some months earlier, he had responded with bitterness, a facet of his character which was to become more pronounced. Bennett was appointed C.M.G. (1915) and twice mentioned in dispatches for his deeds at Gallipoli.

During operations in France, from April 1916 he alternated as battalion and acting brigade commander. On 18 November that year at the Scottish National Church, Chelsea, London, he married Bessie Agnes Buchanan whom he had met in Melbourne. Aged 29, he was promoted temporary brigadier and given the 3rd Brigade on 3 December. His reputation as an exceptional front-line commander grew as a result of his performances at Bullecourt, France (April to May 1917), the Menin Road (September) and Passchendaele (October), Belgium, and again in France at the Hindenburg line from September to November 1918. In contrast, his prickly temperament and tendency to act without orders from divisional headquarters provoked Major General (Sir) William Glasgow to observe: 'Bennett is a pest!' Charles Bean was to recall Bennett's jealousy, criticism of superiors and quarrels with other officers. For his service on the Western Front, Bennett was awarded the Montenegrin Order of Danilo (1917) and the Distinguished Service Order (1919); he was appointed C.B. in 1918 and six times mentioned in dispatches.

After returning briefly to Melbourne, where his A.I.F. appointment terminated on 31 August 1919, he moved to Sydney. There he worked as a clothing manufacturer and a public accountant. In 1922 he was appointed chairman of the State Repatriation Board and in October 1928 became one of the three commissioners administering the City of Sydney. Bennett was prominent in the All for Australia League from 1931 and was a member of the Defence of Australia League. He presided over the Chamber of Manufactures of New South Wales (1931-33), the Associated Chambers of Manufactures of Australia (1933-34) and other professional organizations.

Bennett retained his passion for the army. In 1921-26 he had commanded the 9th Infantry Brigade. He was promoted major general on 1 August 1930 while in command (1926-32) of the 2nd Division. Along with some other citizen-officers in Australia's essentially part-time army, he resented the influence of the handful of regular (Staff Corps) officers. His distaste of permanent-service officers, stemming from earlier experience, increased during two decades of peace. In late 1937 he published a series of newspaper articles on defence policy which criticized regular officers and which led to his being censured by the Military Board.

On the outbreak of World War II Bennett was junior only to Sir Brudenell White and Glasgow, and was in no doubt that, if an Australian expeditionary force were raised, he would be its commander. He was therefore furious when Major General Sir Thomas Blamey (an ex-regular officer with whom he had clashed) was appointed to head the 6th Division and later the A.I.F. The decision to pass over Bennett was not a matter of revenge on the part of politicians and senior Staff Corps officers, as he and his supporters alleged; his military qualities were generally acknowledged. Because of his temperament, he was considered unsuitable for a semi-diplomatic command, and one that involved subordination to British generals. Bennett was as scathing of British officers as he was of Australian regulars.

Worse was to come. On the formation of the A.I.F.'s 7th, 8th and 9th divisions, command in each instance went to others. Bennett languished in Eastern Command until August 1940 when White's sudden death occasioned the appointment of Major General (Sir) Vernon Sturdee as chief of the General Staff. Sturdee nominated Bennett to succeed him as commander of the 8th Division on 24 September. The humiliation of the first year of the war combined with his ambition to spur Bennett to make up lost ground, particularly against Blamey. In February 1941 Bennett flew to Malaya and established his headquarters. He was to be joined by only two of his brigades, the third being detached for service elsewhere. His relationships with his senior officers were unhappy and some of them attempted at one stage to have him recalled on medical grounds. Bennett's dislike of regular officers was unabated and was felt within his command, but his most antagonistic relationship was with Brigadier H. B. Taylor, a former C.M.F. officer. Bennett's dealings with British senior officers, especially with the general officer commanding, Malaya, Lieutenant General A. E. Percival, were similarly devoid of harmony.

Japanese troops landed in Malaya on 8 December and soon pushed British and Indian forces southward. Given command of Westforce on 9 January 1942, Bennett was made responsible for the defence of north-west Johore. He was confident that his Indian and Australian formations would halt the enemy advance, but his dispositions were fundamentally unsound: despite a successful Australian ambush at Gemas on 14 January, he fared no better than the British commanders whom he had derided. By the end of the month the defenders had withdrawn to Singapore. The Japanese assault on 8 February carried all before it. Again, Bennett's conduct of operations was questionable and Percival noted that his interest in the campaign seemed to wane towards the end. Surrender negotiations began on 15 February. That night Bennett handed over command of the 8th Division to Brigadier C. A. Callaghan and left Singapore by sampan. He arrived in Melbourne on 2 March.

The response in Australia to Bennett's escape was mixed. His action was applauded by those who thought that he had valuable lessons to impart on methods of fighting the Japanese. Others, including many senior officers, denounced him for deserting his troops who became prisoners of war. Although Bennett was promoted temporary lieutenant general on 7 April and made commander of III Corps in Perth, Blamey ensured that he would never again have command in the field. Bennett unavailingly petitioned politicians for help. Bitterly disappointed, he transferred to the Reserve of Officers on 9 May 1944. Immediately, he was again at loggerheads with military authorities over his account of the Malayan campaign, Why Singapore Fell (Sydney), which was largely an apologia. Although Blamey tried to prevent the book's publication, it came out later that year.

On the release of prisoners of war in 1945, a letter from Percival which accused Bennett of unlawfully vacating his command was passed to Blamey. A military investigation found that Bennett had relinquished his command without permission. The reaction of his defenders, many of whom had served with him in World War I or in the 8th Division, was vociferous and the government commissioned (Sir) George Ligertwood to inquire into the matter. The commissioner's findings failed to provide Bennett with the vindication he sought. While never questioning Bennett's personal courage, Ligertwood concluded that his action had been unjustified.

Bennett's stated reason for leaving Singapore was that he had learned how to defeat the Japanese (but had been let down by British and Indian troops) and he was obliged to communicate his knowledge to military authorities. Yet, he had proved no more proficient than other commanders in Malaya and his tactics were outdated. Just as important to him was his wish to lead the Australian army, a consuming aspiration which had been sharpened by not being given an early command. His prejudice against regular officers and his ambition clouded his professional judgement at the most important point in his career. When his most cherished goals were in tatters, he convinced himself that blame for his failure lay with others.

After the war Bennett became an orchardist at Glenorie, near Sydney, until 1955. He continued his interest in military matters and wrote articles on many topics, among them the virtues of a citizen army. Survived by his wife and daughter, he died on 1 August 1962 at Dural and was cremated with Anglican rites. His portrait by James Quinn is held by the Australian War Memorial, Canberra.

 

Citation details
A. B. Lodge, 'Bennett, Henry Gordon (1887–1962)', Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University, http://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/bennett-henry-gordon-9489/text16697, published first in hardcopy 1993, accessed online 5 January 2021.

This article was first published in hardcopy in Australian Dictionary of Biography, Volume 13, (MUP), 1993

Read more...